Monday, July 16, 2007

Is the fifth Potter film as good as the book?


Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix has opened to rave reviews, with fans calling it the best of the series so far. Purists, however, will always prefer J K Rowling's books to the movies.

There's magic, and then there's magic.


The real charm of the Harry Potter books, as any Pottermaniac will vouch for, is not so much in the fantastic spells the boy wizard and his friends learn at the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, but the magic of human emotions.


You don't have to be a fantasy fan to like Harry Potter; the core of the books is closer to P G Wodehouse school stories than Tolkien. That's what the four films before Order Of The Phoenix failed to grasp.


There were special effects galore, but you didn't feel Harry's emptiness every time a school year ended. You didn't feel his goodness, and you didn't grow with him

No comments: